INCOME TAX Reassessment proceedings u/s 148- Validity of notices issued u/s 148A(b) & 148A(d)

Reassessment proceedings u/s 148- Validity of notices issued u/s 148A(b) & 148A(d)

Reassessment proceedings u/s 148- Validity of notices issued u/s 148A(b) & 148A(d)

Reassessment proceedings u/s 148- Validity of notices issued u/s 148A(b) & 148A(d) – In the Amalgamation.

Sonansh Creations Pvt Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax and Anr. Case No.: W.P.(C) 12316/202

Background: A notice u/s 148A(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was issued to M/s Tulsi, a company that had ceased to exist after merging with Sonali Realtech (the Petitioner). The Petitioner responded, informing the Assessing Officer of the merger. Subsequently, notices u/s 148A(d) & Section 148 were issued in the name of the petitioner.

Key Issues: The validity of notices issued u/s 148A(b) & 148A(d), given the amalgamation. Whether reassessment proceedings were initiated correctly u/s 148.

High Court's Observations:

  • Nature of Section 148A Proceedings: These enable the Assessing Officer to decide if reassessment proceedings u/s 147 should be initiated, ensuring no arbitrary reopening of assessments.
  • Petitioner’s Response: The Petitioner informed the Assessing Officer about the merger, and the Assessing Officer considered this while issuing notices u/s 148A(d) & Section 148 in the Petitioner’s name.
  • Distinction from Maruti Suzuki Case: Unlike the Maruti Suzuki judgment, where proceedings were invalidated due to notices being issued to a non-existent entity, in this case, the reassessment notice u/s 148 was correctly addressed to the Petitioner as the successor entity.

Court's Decision: Assessing Officer validly initiated proceedings u/s 148 in the Petitioner’s name based on the material provided, adhering to the procedure prescribed under Section 148A. However, the reassessment proceedings were set aside due to the Assessing Officer lack of material evidence to substantiate the allegations of income escaping assessment

The Delhi High Court upheld the validity of the procedural steps taken u/s 148A & Section 148 but allowed the Petitioner’s objections to the reassessment due to insufficient material supporting the allegations.

PCIT vs. Capital Power Systems Ltd. Court: Delhi High Court Appeal No.: ITA 501/2024


Issue: Whether reassessment proceedings u/s 148 were valid when based on Section 150, despite time limits prescribed u/s 149.

Background of the Case:

  • Search and Discovery: During a search u/s 132 of the Income Tax Act, the CEO and Director, Mr. Pawan Kumar Bansal, surrendered ₹7 crores as undisclosed income. In his ITR for Assessment Year  2007-08, Mr. Bansal disclosed only ₹20 lakhs, leaving ₹6.8 crores unaccounted.
  • Protective and Substantive Additions: The AO made protective additions of ₹3.45 crores to Capital Power Systems Ltd. and substantive additions to Mr. Bansal's personal income.
  • ITAT’s Decision: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ruled in favor of Capital Power Systems Ltd., dismissing the protective additions.
  • Reassessment Proceedings: The revenue department invoked Section 150 to reopen the assessment u/s 148, claiming the
    Income Tax Appellate Tribunal order justified reassessment despite time limitations u/s 149.

Key Provisions and Revenue’s Argument:

  • Section 150(1): Permits reassessment beyond normal time limits if it arises from an appellate authority's order.
  • Section 150(2): Imposes a restriction that reassessments cannot exceed time limits if the time had already expired before the appellate authority passed its order.
  • Revenue’s Stand:Claimed the reassessment was valid u/s 150(1) as the
    Income Tax Appellate Tribunal order highlighted the undisclosed income originally identified during the search proceedings.

High Court’s Analysis:

  • Misapplication of Section 150(1): The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal order did not create any fresh liability or findings necessitating reassessment. Instead, it resolved the issue in favor of Capital Power Systems Ltd. Section 150(1) could not apply as the
    Income Tax Appellate Tribunal order did not suggest income escaping assessment.
  • Violation of Section 150(2): The time limit for reassessment for AY 2007-08 had already expired before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's order.  Invoking Section 150 to override these time limits was legally impermissible.
  • Protective vs. Substantive Assessments: Protective assessments are contingent and cannot independently justify reassessment, especially when resolved against the revenue in appellate proceedings.

Court’s Decision: The Delhi High Court quashed the reassessment proceedings, holding that: Section 150(1) cannot be invoked if the appellate order does not indicate any income escaping assessment. Time limitations u/s 150(2) must be adhered to, and reassessments cannot be initiated once these limits have expired. This judgment reinforces that Section 150 is not a tool to circumvent statutory time limits for reassessment. The decision safeguards taxpayers against arbitrary and time-barred proceedings, ensuring compliance with procedural safeguards in the Income Tax Act.

Disclaimer: The content of this post isn't considered to be professional or legal advice, We aren't responsible for any damages arising from your access to the location content & must not be relied on or used as a substitute for legal advice from a lawyer professional in your jurisdiction. CARajput is among India's big digital compliance services platform which committed to helping people have started & developed their businesses. We had started with the goal of creating it easier for start-ups to start out their business. Our main aim is to assist the businessman with applicable laws & regulations compliance and providing support at each & every level to make sure the business stays compliant and growing continuously. For any query, help or feedback you may in touch on singh@carajput.com or Call or what’s-up on 9-555-555-480

Share This Post

Related Articles

Related Videos


E.FILING OF INCOME TAX RETURN | What is e-filing of income tax | Steps to file

E.filing of Income Tax Return | What is e-filing of income tax | Steps to file

Published On: Jan 03, 2022 | By: RJA

Need help?

Request a call
from a RJA
Business Advisor.

LET'S TALK

Private Limited Company

Popular Categories

Browse Blogs

Recent Posts

Budget Finance Bill, 2025 (Union Budget 2025-26) Proposals By

Budget Finance Bill, 2025 (Union Budget 2025-26) Proposals By

ICAI Announces May 2025 Exam Dates & Centers schedule:

ICAI Announces May 2025 Exam Dates & Centers schedule:

Landmark Supreme Court judgments concerning homebuyers' rights are safeguarded

Landmark Supreme Court judgments concerning homebuyers' rights are safeguarded

Highlights on Extended deadline for declaring foreign assets & ITRs

Highlights on Extended deadline for declaring foreign assets & ITRs

Encouraging Restructuring Over Liquidation in the IBC Framework

Encouraging Restructuring Over Liquidation in the IBC Framework

Connect with a RJA Advisor

Fields marked with an * are required

Enquire Us

Please send us your query and we feel very happy helping you

Testimonials

  • Thank you very much for all your help in setting up my new company and clearing up all outstanding business in my sole trader accounts. For the first time in years I have peace of mind regards my business accounts. Your workforce are a credit to you, the girls at reception are so helpful and Chris has been brilliant. It is very much appreciated.

    A US consultancy group

  • Rajput Jain & Associates. are a tremendous value added to me as an executive and a busy parent. It just makes sense to delegate my tax file to them -- they are proactive, extremely service oriented, and most importantly, I am completely confident they are finding every dollar of tax savings available to me.

    A Leading Service Provider

  • We use Rajput Jain & Associates for all our accounting, Corporation tax, VAT and other compliance needs. The service is professional, courteous and prompt. I would recommend Rajput Jain & Associates to any company requiring a comprehensive accounting and tax service.

    A Leading Consultancy Firm in Dubai

Money Back Guarantee

Not happy with the service? You can request a refund at anytime within 30 days!

24/7 Support

Get support through phone, email, mobile app or live chat - 24/7, 365 days.

EMI Payment

Easily pay online with EMI payments, credit or debit card, net banking, PayPal and more.

Get In Touch--

Rajput Jain & Associates

Add: P-60, Connaught Circus, Connaught Place, New Delhi-110001

Email: singh@carajput.com

Phone: 9555555480

Legal Disclaimer--

The information contained on this website merely provides details of our firm to persons who have shown interest in knowing more about us and is not intended to solicit work or advertise our capabilities in any manner. The information provided on this website is general in nature and should not be used as a basis of decision-making without further professional advice. The third party site links are only provided for ready reference of the users and CA Rajput Jain & Associates neither controls their content nor undertakes any responsibility regarding them.

© 2016 Rajput Jain & Associates. All Rights Reserved | Sitemap

Call Email