Old vs New Tax Regime –Evaluate each year before choosing

Old vs New Tax Regime: Evaluate each year before choosing.

With ITR filing season around the corner, here’s the biggest question for every salaried individual. Should I opt for the Old Regime or the New Regime? After Budget 2023 & 2024, the New Regime has become the default, offering

• Lower slab rates
• Higher standard deduction of INR 75,000 (vs. INR 50,000 in the Old Regime)

But is it always the better option? Let’s break it down:

Deductions in the New Tax Regime (Union Budget 2025 Update)

The Union Budget 2025 reinforced the New Tax Regime as the default option for individuals, aiming to simplify taxation and offer more flexibility. While it comes with reduced slab rates and a higher standard deduction, most traditional exemptions available under the Old Tax Regime have been removed.

Choosing between the two depends on your income, deductions, and financial goals. Let’s break it down.

Understanding the New Tax Regime

• Simplified filing: No need to maintain proofs for HRA, 80C, medical bills, etc.
• Standard Deduction: INR 75,000 (for salaried individuals & pensioners).
• Tax slabs (FY 2025–26):

Income Range	Tax Rate
Up to INR 2.5 lakh	Nil
INR 2.5 – INR 5 lakh	5%
INR 5 – INR 7.5 lakh	10%
INR 7.5 – INR 10 lakh	15%
INR 10 – INR 12.5 lakh	20%
INR 12.5 – INR 15 lakh	25%
Above INR 15 lakh	30%

Best for: Individuals who do not claim many deductions and prefer simplicity.

What is the Old Tax Regime?

The Old Regime allows taxpayers to reduce taxable income through various deductions and exemptions, making it ideal for active tax planners. Key Deductions/Exemptions under Old Regime:

• 80C – Up to INR 1.5 lakh (PPF, ELSS, life insurance, EPF, etc.)
• 80D – Health insurance premium (INR 25,000 / INR 50,000 for senior citizens) Even though 80D deduction isn’t available in the New Regime, health insurance remains crucial for financial security against rising medical costs. It ensures protection against hospitalisation expenses, regardless of tax savings.
• HRA – Exemption on house rent paid (subject to conditions)
• 24(b) – Home loan interest (up to INR 2 lakh)
• 80E – Education loan interest
• 80G – Donations
• 80U – Disability benefit (INR 75,000 to INR 1.25 lakh)
• Standard Deduction – INR 50,000

Best for: Individuals with high deductions/investments.

Old vs New Tax Regime: How to Decide

• Go with Old Regime if → you claim large deductions (PF, ELSS, insurance, HRA, home loan interest, medical bills).
• Go with New Regime if → you have fewer deductions and prefer a hassle-free filing process.

Compare your liability under both regimes before filing your return.

Example :

• Old Regime (with deductions like 80C + 80D + 24b): Lower taxable income → lower tax payable.
• New Regime (no deductions): No exemptions, but lower rates may still reduce liability.

Deductions & Exemptions 

• Old Regime: HRA, 80C, home loan interest, NPS, insurance & more.
• New Regime: Limited deductions but higher standard deduction.

Income Level –

• Higher deductions claimed? Old Regime may still save more.
• Few/no deductions? New Regime’s revised slabs work better.

Simplicity vs Flexibility –

• New Regime: Cleaner, less paperwork.
• Old Regime: Needs tax planning but offers flexibility & savings levers.

Lifestyle & Goals –

• Already investing in PPF, ELSS, NPS, insurance, etc.? : – Old Regime fits.
• Prefer liquidity & not locking funds for tax savings? : – New Regime is ideal.

comparative calculation for A.Y. 2025-26:

• Case 1: Employee with high deductions → Old Regime wins
• Case 2: Employee with no deductions → New Regime wins

Old vs New Tax Regime: Real-Life Example

Case 1: Employee with High Deductions

• Old Regime Tax Payable: INR 59,800
• New Regime Tax Payable: INR 71,500 then Old Regime is Beneficial

Case 2: Employee with No Major Deductions

• Old Regime Tax Payable: INR 1,63,800
• New Regime Tax Payable: INR 71,500 then we can say that New Regime is Beneficial

Conclusion

Both tax regimes have merits:

• Old Regime : better for planners with multiple deductions.
• New Regime : simpler and cleaner for those without major tax-saving investments.

Evaluate your finances each year before choosing. And remember, insurance, savings, and investments should be driven by your financial needs — not just tax benefits.

If you maximise deductions (80C, NPS, Mediclaim, Home Loan), the Old Regime saves more. If you don’t claim many deductions, the New Regime’s lower slabs win. The best regime depends on your financial habits & savings style, not just income.