Page Contents
| Particulars | Gold ETFs | Silver ETFs |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of Asset | Tracks the price of gold bullion | Tracks the price of silver bullion |
| Volatility | Comparatively less volatile and more stable | More volatile with larger price fluctuations |
| Primary Demand Driver | Investment, central bank reserves, jewellery demand, safe-haven buying | Industrial demand (electronics, solar panels, EVs) along with investment demand |
| Safe-Haven Status | Considered a traditional safe-haven asset during economic uncertainty | Less of a safe-haven asset and more influenced by economic cycles |
| Risk Level | Lower risk | Higher risk |
| Liquidity | Generally higher trading volumes and liquidity | Comparatively lower liquidity |
| Price Movement | Relatively stable and gradual | Can witness sharp upward or downward movements |
| Inflation Hedge | Strong inflation hedge | Inflation hedge, but more dependent on industrial demand trends |
| Return Potential | Moderate and steady long-term returns | Higher return potential, but with higher risk |
| Economic Sensitivity | Less dependent on industrial growth | Highly sensitive to industrial growth and manufacturing activity |
| Portfolio Role | Wealth preservation and risk diversification | Growth-oriented exposure to precious metals |
| Suitable For | Conservative investors seeking stability | Aggressive investors willing to accept higher volatility |
| Market Behaviour During Crisis | Usually performs well during market uncertainty | May decline if industrial demand weakens |
| Taxation | STCG: Slab Rate (<12 months); LTCG: 12.5% (>12 months) | STCG: Slab Rate (<12 months); LTCG: 12.5% (>12 months) |
| Investment Objective | Capital protection and portfolio hedge | Growth and participation in industrial metal demand |
Question: Regularly trading of gold & silver ETFs during FY 2025-26, 559 buys & 559 sells, all bought & sold executed within a week, max 111 days, having some closing stock in is eligible under which code in Business & Profession in ITR3?
Answer: Business Code 21011 – Buying and Selling of Shares (Delivery-Based Trading as Business Income)
For a person who has regularly traded gold ETFs and silver ETFs during FY 2025-26 with 559 purchase transactions and 559 sale transactions, most holdings were sold within a week (maximum holding period 111 days), with frequent and systematic trading activity and Some units remaining as closing stock at year-end.
the activity is more likely to be treated as business income rather than capital gains, based on the volume, frequency, and intention of trading. CBDT Circular No. 6/2016 also recognizes that frequent trading may be treated as business income.
If offered as business income:
For 559 buy and 559 sell transactions, I would generally recommend filing ITR-3, Offer income under Profits and Gains of Business or Profession, and selecting Nature of Business Code 21011 and maintaining a record of turnover and profit/loss from ETF trading, so we have to check the applicability of tax audit u/s 44AB based on turnover and other conditions. In this case we have to use Business Code 21011 – Buying and Selling of Shares (Delivery-Based Trading as Business Income)
| ETF Type | STCG Tax | LTCG Tax | Holding Period for LTCG |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equity ETFs | 20% | 12.5% on gains exceeding INR 1.25 lakh | More than 12 months |
| Gold ETFs | Slab Rate | 12.5% (No Indexation) | More than 12 months |
| Silver ETFs | Slab Rate | 12.5% (No Indexation) | More than 12 months |
| Debt ETFs* | Slab Rate | Depends on applicable provisions | Depends on fund structure |
While Equity ETFs receive concessional equity taxation, Gold and Silver ETFs are taxed as listed non-equity securities, and Debt ETFs require a closer examination of their underlying investment composition before determining the applicable tax treatment.
Recent Amendments to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016: What Insolvency Professionals Need to Know The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code,… Read More
Tax Audit Applicability for F&O Traders – AY 2026-27 (FY 2025-26) A futures & options (F&O) trader is required to… Read More
Prevention of Sexual Harassment at the Workplace: Beyond Compliance Towards a Culture of Dignity and Respect Introduction The workplace has… Read More
Who Needs to Register with FIU-IND? The Financial Intelligence Unit-India (FIU-IND) is the government agency responsible for monitoring and preventing… Read More
Revision & Rectification Provisions under the Income-tax Act, 2025 vs the Income-tax Act, 1961 Understanding the Key Changes in Revision… Read More
DPDP Act, 2023: 7 Major Penalty Areas Every Business Should Know The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, marks a… Read More