Page Contents
| Particulars | Gold ETFs | Silver ETFs |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of Asset | Tracks the price of gold bullion | Tracks the price of silver bullion |
| Volatility | Comparatively less volatile and more stable | More volatile with larger price fluctuations |
| Primary Demand Driver | Investment, central bank reserves, jewellery demand, safe-haven buying | Industrial demand (electronics, solar panels, EVs) along with investment demand |
| Safe-Haven Status | Considered a traditional safe-haven asset during economic uncertainty | Less of a safe-haven asset and more influenced by economic cycles |
| Risk Level | Lower risk | Higher risk |
| Liquidity | Generally higher trading volumes and liquidity | Comparatively lower liquidity |
| Price Movement | Relatively stable and gradual | Can witness sharp upward or downward movements |
| Inflation Hedge | Strong inflation hedge | Inflation hedge, but more dependent on industrial demand trends |
| Return Potential | Moderate and steady long-term returns | Higher return potential, but with higher risk |
| Economic Sensitivity | Less dependent on industrial growth | Highly sensitive to industrial growth and manufacturing activity |
| Portfolio Role | Wealth preservation and risk diversification | Growth-oriented exposure to precious metals |
| Suitable For | Conservative investors seeking stability | Aggressive investors willing to accept higher volatility |
| Market Behaviour During Crisis | Usually performs well during market uncertainty | May decline if industrial demand weakens |
| Taxation | STCG: Slab Rate (<12 months); LTCG: 12.5% (>12 months) | STCG: Slab Rate (<12 months); LTCG: 12.5% (>12 months) |
| Investment Objective | Capital protection and portfolio hedge | Growth and participation in industrial metal demand |
Question: Regularly trading of gold & silver ETFs during FY 2025-26, 559 buys & 559 sells, all bought & sold executed within a week, max 111 days, having some closing stock in is eligible under which code in Business & Profession in ITR3?
Answer: Business Code 21011 – Buying and Selling of Shares (Delivery-Based Trading as Business Income)
For a person who has regularly traded gold ETFs and silver ETFs during FY 2025-26 with 559 purchase transactions and 559 sale transactions, most holdings were sold within a week (maximum holding period 111 days), with frequent and systematic trading activity and Some units remaining as closing stock at year-end.
the activity is more likely to be treated as business income rather than capital gains, based on the volume, frequency, and intention of trading. CBDT Circular No. 6/2016 also recognizes that frequent trading may be treated as business income.
If offered as business income:
For 559 buy and 559 sell transactions, I would generally recommend filing ITR-3, Offer income under Profits and Gains of Business or Profession, and selecting Nature of Business Code 21011 and maintaining a record of turnover and profit/loss from ETF trading, so we have to check the applicability of tax audit u/s 44AB based on turnover and other conditions. In this case we have to use Business Code 21011 – Buying and Selling of Shares (Delivery-Based Trading as Business Income)
| ETF Type | STCG Tax | LTCG Tax | Holding Period for LTCG |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equity ETFs | 20% | 12.5% on gains exceeding INR 1.25 lakh | More than 12 months |
| Gold ETFs | Slab Rate | 12.5% (No Indexation) | More than 12 months |
| Silver ETFs | Slab Rate | 12.5% (No Indexation) | More than 12 months |
| Debt ETFs* | Slab Rate | Depends on applicable provisions | Depends on fund structure |
While Equity ETFs receive concessional equity taxation, Gold and Silver ETFs are taxed as listed non-equity securities, and Debt ETFs require a closer examination of their underlying investment composition before determining the applicable tax treatment.
TDS on Purchase of Property from an NRI: PAN-Based Compliance Replaces TAN from 1 October 2026 The Government has significantly… Read More
RBI Relaxes FEMA Export-Import Reporting for Service Exporters and Importers Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has simplified FEMA compliance requirements… Read More
Complete Guide to Limited Liability Partnership A Limited Liability Partnership is a hybrid business structure that combines the operational flexibility… Read More
ROC Provisions Relating to Directors under the Companies Act, 2013 The provisions relating to directors under the Companies Act, 2013… Read More
New GST Registration Guidelines from 1 November 2026 As per New GST Registration Guidelines from 1st Nov 2026 - As per Circular-No-257-03-2026… Read More
CSR Policy: Activities under Schedule VII and CSR Implementation through Eligible Agencies The framework of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) under… Read More