Categories: Insolvency

Approve Resolution Plan binding only on Party Involved Plan

 

www.carajput.com; IBBI

Approved Resolution Plan is binding only on those parties involved in the resolution plan-Electrosteel Steels Limited Vs. The state of Jharkhand – Jharkhand High Court

The ruling of the High Court: I.

The tax collected from customers is not “Operation Debt” in accordance with the Code:

The amount of VAT had to be paid by the applicant Company to the customers. In that regard, it is questionable whether the amount of VAT is covered by the terms ‘debt in respect of payment of duties arising under any law for the time being in force and payable to the central government of any State Government,'[(Sec. 5(21)] in order to bring it within the definition of ‘operational debt,’ as defined in the Code.

This tax burden can very well be allowed to treat as the amount of tax already accrued by the applicant Company from its customers, on behalf of the Government of the State, and not the direct debt of the petitioner Company to the Government of the State.

In which case the tax liabilities of the petitioner Company, in respect of which the disputed garnishee order has been issued, may not fall within the scope of the definition.

Decisions cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner at Embassy Property Developments Pvt. The case of Ltd., and in the case of Monnet Ispat and Energy Ltd., is of no help to the applicant company as it relates to income tax fees, which were the direct debts of the corporate debtors in those cases.

Read Also: Drafting and Negotiating of Resolution plan under CIRP under IBC

II. The amendment to Sec. 31(1) of the approved resolution plan, binding on the Government Authorities is prospective in nature:

It is also appropriate to mention here that Section 31(1) of the 2016 Code was amended empty IBC (Amendment) Act, 2019, in order to make the approved resolution plan binding on the government authorities in relation to the statutory fees. It is pursuant to this amendment that the rights of the Government Authorities for statutory fees have been affected and that right has been made subject to the approved resolution plan.

The said amendment was made effective from 16.08.2019, which is prospective in nature, and there was no express retroactive effect on the said amendment. This amendment removes the substantive right of the Government Authorities in relation to statutory fees and therefore any interpretations thereof. It would be unreasonable and unfair to give a retrospective effect to the said amendment.

Also, read the relevant blogs:

Rajput Jain & Associates

Rajput Jain & Associates is a Chartered Accountants firm, with it's headquarter situated at New Delhi (the capital of India). The firm has been set up by a group of young, enthusiastic, highly skilled and motivated professionals who have taken experience from top consulting firms and are extensively experienced in their chosen fields has providing a wide array of Accounting, Auditing, Taxation, Assurance and Business advisory services to various clients and their stakeholders. Rajput jain & Associates, a professional firm, offers its clients a full range of services, To serve better and to bring bucket of services under one roof, the firm has merged with it various Chartered Accountancy firms pioneer in diversified fields. We have associates all over India in big cities. All our offices are well equipped with latest technological support with updated reference materials. We have a large team of professionals other than our Core Team members to meet the requirements of our prospective clients including the existing ones. However, considering our commitment towards high quality services to our clients, our team keeps on growing with more and more associates having strong professional background with good exposure in the related areas of responsibility.

Recent Posts

Debate on Reservation System in CA, CS, & CMA

Reservation in CA, CS & CMA: A Detailed Debate Perspective The discussion around introducing reservation in professional courses such as… Read More

1 day ago

DCF Is Out: Only NAV for Valuation of Unquoted Equity Shares

DCF Is Out: Rule 57 Prescribes Only NAV for Valuation of Unquoted Equity Shares The introduction of the Income-tax Rules,… Read More

3 days ago

Advertisement Enabled Era of CA Practice: ICAI Relaxes Norms

Advertisement Enabled Era of CA Practice: ICAI Relaxes Publicity Norms Effective 1 April 2026, the revised ICAI Code of Ethics,… Read More

4 days ago

Govt Notified use of Aadhaar Authentication for UCDP

Aadhaar Authentication for Good Governance : Dept of Development-IT The Department of Development-IT, Government of India, has issued a public… Read More

4 days ago

PAN-Based Compliance Replaces TAN from 1 Oct 2026

TDS on Purchase of Property from an NRI: PAN-Based Compliance Replaces TAN from 1 October 2026 The Government has significantly… Read More

1 week ago

RBI Relaxe FEMA Reporting for Service Exporters & Importer

RBI Relaxes FEMA Export-Import Reporting for Service Exporters and Importers Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has simplified FEMA compliance requirements… Read More

1 week ago
Call Us Enquire Now